On the other hand, timprov and I are watching Season 1 Veronica Mars on DVD for the first time*, and it's a joy, because if you poke it with your brain, it pokes back rather than falling apart. The big plotty things, obviously, but little stupid things, too -- like Veronica knowing how to do a million things with her hair to make herself look different. You can look at that and think, "Of course a girl who was best friends with someone like Lilly Kane would know that kind of thing." The characterization fits. The places where it doesn't make sense are places where people don't make sense -- why is a basically decent, if boring and spoiled and pouty, kid like Duncan Kane friends with a waste of oxygen like Logan Eccles? Well, there were always guys like that in high school, "popular" kids where one was pretty decent, if willing to let his friend go too far, and the other was a total shit. (Girls, too, but the dynamic is different.) And then, as if that wasn't enough, they know how to humanize the waste of space while still leaving him a waste of space.
This is why I get annoyed when people say, "It's only a movie/TV show." Certainly it is; it's not a cure for cancer or an end to poverty or etc. etc. etc. But movies and TV shows are art forms, too, and they can do things well when they bother. And there's really no point to insulting entire art forms just to justify one example that didn't do very well.
*So please do not post plot spoilers in the comments to this post. This is a very plotty show. For the most part, I don't mind spoilers much, but this time I really want to see how they feed the information out over the different installments. I can skip posts in other people's journals, whether or not they use cut-tags. But please leave plot points out of mine.